|
| You might as well burn your books than be in publisher hell. |
I was advised by other writers not to write a blog about my
experience with John Hunt Publishing.
"It could ruin your future writing career," a writer friend said.
"It might make you sound like you're a nightmare to deal with," said
another.
Of course I thought about it. These guys know what they're talking about. They
were concerned about me. But, in the end I decided that I had to write this
blog because other authors deserve to know what they might get into if they
sign up with this publisher. And how can they know anything if authors don't
share information?
Besides, I know the points I make are valid. I didn’t just
write the books and sit back and expect them to sell. I put my heart and soul
into them and worked 100-hour weeks to promote them. I felt let down that I was
the only one trying to sell my books. At times, I felt like John Hunt
Publishing were sabotaging me.
When John Hunt Publishing offered me a contract, I looked around the web for
information and found very little. I wish I'd known then what I know now
because my relationship with them was a nightmare.
It started off well enough. Their readers' reports were extremely positive.
Comments like "what's not to love here" and "this could sell in the
thousands." And, I had a right to have high hopes. I’m an award-winning
writing and have been writing for 20-odd years.
Then the reality started to bite and what I found is the
most disappointing experience I’ve ever had in 13 years of getting books published
-
JHP make a big thing
about their marketing and their author database, both of which sound
impressive, but they didn't deliver.
- The database had important details missing like email addresses, phone
numbers and contact details.
- You had to pay for any real marketing - You had to pay for
any marketing that went beyond sending automated press releases that are
cobbled together with the words authors put in their proposals. Yes, in my case
and many other authors, the press release was generated word for word by the
words I put in the proposal. The way the online system worked, you could see
the proposals authors inputted and their press releases. There was no effort on
the part of the staff. In my case, a basic spell check wasn't even done. This
marketing cost 150 for 6 hours of work, which seemed to involve them doing
pretty little.
Valuable marketing and promotional opportunities were
wasted
For example, over a number of months I worked towards getting my book Hell To Pay featured in a top newspaper with a 250, 000 readership.
I knew 2
weeks in advance that my book would be featured and told the marketing
department. I stupidly thought because the book was set in Glasgow
and the newspaper was based in Glasgow
that the publisher would contact the big bookstores in the city, including Waterstone’s
and say, "Hey, one of our books will be featured in the country's
bestselling newspaper, would you like some on a sale or return basis?"
They did absolutely nothing and wasted the opportunity. Yes, free publicity
that money can't buy, that they were notified about two weeks in advance and
they did nothing.
I felt demoralised. That my time had been completely wasted.
That my publisher they didn't care about whether my book sold or not.
I was contacted by several people who saw my book and told me they tried to buy
my book in a store and it wasn't for sale.
John Hunt Publishing missed a golden opportunity to sell more books.
Note - I could have contacted bookshops myself, but my royalty on paperbacks was 10 percent and the publisher's was 90 percent.
There was a catalogue
of errors in the book listing.
They wrongly spelt my surname on all the book sites and I had to get it changed
myself. That was made more difficult because it was the publisher who were
meant to make changes, not the author.
They didn't even
check sites had my books and others correctly categorised.
For instance, Throwaways, my novella about murdered Glasgow sex workers was listed as erotic
fiction and also as true life, which was news to my family.
There was a pattern
of disrespect, pithy and aggressive behaviour from staff.
They have a closed online forum for authors and after repeatedly being ignored
about certain issues, I started to post on the Facebook page - a few posts,
written in a friendly way - that's when without a word I was kicked off FB and
the JHP forum with no explanation after one of the head honchos at the
publisher accused me of "aggressive and bullying behaviour." I asked
others on the page if they thought that had been the case and nobody did.
Seven authors sent me a message saying that their experience
of JHP had been very poor and they wanted their rights back. Eventually, I was
given ALL my rights back, but only because I suspect they wanted rid of
me.
When I politely asked
why my books imprint didn't appear on their fiction blog alongside a few
others, I was told my imprint was MBS even although over half the books were
fiction and my books were CRIME FICTION.
When I asked why certain marketing tasks weren't done, I'd
get answers that were more "go away" than "we want to sell
books."
Contracts offered
were often contributory meaning you were paying to get published. Cue alarm bells.
Before they signed me up, they made it sound like they only asked for
contributions when the book in question was niche, but once I was allowed onto
the forum I discovered there was a very high amount of authors who'd paid huge
sums, despite what the publisher claimed. And those books were far from niche.
One was even entered for a fiction award by the publisher.
Many authors queried their contracts on the online forum and those contracts
seemed to average 2-3 thousand pounds. Note - that was just for editing. They
also paid for marketing. One author I know spent over £4, 000 in total.
To me, that's a publisher taking advantage of an author's dream at a time when
very none of the big publishers accept contributions unless you have an agent.
They charged for your
book to be converted into an eBook.
No, I'm not kidding. Both my novellas cost around £60. It was deducted from
royalties.
NO LEGITIMATE PUBLISHER SHOULD CHARGE TO CONVERT YOUR BOOK.
Later on, they came up with the bright
idea of charging £100 to put your book into print. Yeah, really. After
complaints they decided not to go ahead.
In conclusion -
- I believe John Hunt Publishing take advantage of the lines being blurred
between vanity presses and self publishing. They charge for many authors’ services
like editing and marketing.
- They should tell you BEFORE you submit the initial query
that they may charge you for services that every other traditional publisher
does gratis. Things like editing, proof reading and marketing that goes beyond
sending automated press releases that are cobbled together with the words
authors put in their proposals. Yes, in my case and many other authors, the
press release was generated word for word by the words I put in the proposal.
The way the online system worked, you could see the proposals authors inputted
and their press releases. There was no effort on the part of the staff. In my
case, a basic spell check wasn't even done.
- Many awards are not open to people who paid towards the
cost of being published, which many authors did. Because the lines between
self-publishing and vanity publishing are so blurred, authors who paid towards
the cost of their books being published often thought that they would still be
considered to be traditionally published and could enter these awards.
Truth was, they were ineligible.
What have I learned?
1. If a publisher has contracts where you contribute financially (on any level)
avoid them like the plague. They're a vanity publisher.
2. If a publisher talks about their wonderful marketing,
have a look at what they actually do. Do they have a strong social media
presence? Do they have a list of blogs who review their books? Do they have
readers groups - something JHP promised on their home page, but never produced?
3. If they charge fees for eBook conversion, they're a
vanity publisher.
I was charged for both my books. A genuine publisher
shouldn't charge you a penny. A vanity publisher will.
4. If a publisher charges you a penny for marketing/promotion, avoid
them - JHP did very basic marketing. So basic in fact, that press releases were
simply lifted from authors and in my case, not even given a basic spell check.
The very same publicists who did the promo for books wanted £150 each time to
do 6 hours of publicity. That included things that most publishers did as a
matter of course. A genuine publisher shouldn't charge you a penny. A vanity
publisher will. Note - before I signed my contracts I didn't know they charged
like this.
In conclusion, I would advise anyone to self-publish rather
than sign up with John Hunt Publishing. Before you know it, like many of their
authors, you could end up with a huge dent in your bank balance as you pay for
editing and marketing and promotion. All things a traditional publisher should
be providing for free.
Thankfully, although they published Hell to Pay and
Throwaways, I didn't give this bunch a penny and when I self-published the
books, I sold 6 times more books than they ever did.
Note - this is my experience with John Hunt Publishing.
Other authors may have had a more positive experience.
